Welcome to Pizza Paul's
At Pizza Paul's, located in the heart of Geneseo, NY, a culinary legacy continues to thrive. Born from a passion for authentic flavors, Pizza Paul's offers more than just pizza; it's a community gathering place. The menu features delectable options, including perfectly cooked pizzas and hearty subs, all made with fresh ingredients. Customers rave about the generous toppings and signature double dough crusts. The warm atmosphere is complemented by friendly staff who go the extra mile to cater to every palate. From cheesy breadsticks to tantalizing wings, every bite embodies a commitment to quality and cherished memories. Come and discover your new favorite slice!
Pizza Paul's: Reviews & Ratings
Their cheesy breadsticks are a medium white pizza in all but name, but they absolutely kill it and make me want more every time.
Perfectly cooked pizza and wings. Fast service. Great prices. Can you ask for anything better? I love the flavor of the BBQ wings and the crust is PERFECT. We get pizza here weekly. We have never had a bad experience. I miss the late owner but his crew is still going strong. See you next week!!
A great little place, and most importantly: more than solid pizza. A cheese slice the size of a plate for less than 5.00, and you won’t regret it for a second. Also has a ton of other options besides pizza, including calzones and subs.
Best pizza ever!! Sauce is yummy and the quantity of toppings is just right... consistently. Their double dough pizza is great and is our favorite way of enjoying pizza. We added mushrooms to our pizza the other day and they used fresh mushrooms. Please go here, you won't be disappointed. We moved away a couple years ago, but every time we're in the area we make a special trip to Pizza Paul's to take back home with us.
We love this place. Having an autistic son we are constantly dealing with his picky easting. I decided to choose my battles but consistently offer new foods to try. In the meantime he loves garlic bread with cheese. They've gotten to know us and have even made a large version for him. Also the regular pizza and wings are also great.
We had a large order for delivery tonight. The delivery arrived before scheduled time. All the food was hot, fresh and made to order. Everything was delicious. We were very pleased and would highly recommend!
Haven't had a bad meal here yet! In Buffalo we have "" stinger subs"" which are steak with sausage. When I ask that they put the sausage they use on pizza on my steak sub they gladly comply. Amazing subs. Awesome pizza. Always friendly staff-( please tip them well- they are great!)
As a commuting student, this used to be my go-to spot when I didn't bring a lunch with me. I’m a big pizza lover, so when Pizza Paul's was recommended to me by one of my professors, I had to try it. I got my first slice here on my first week attending Geneseo. The pizza was a little different than what I was used to, but I kept coming back and it really grew on me. The Buffalo slice was my favorite. Fair pricing. Good flavor. Quick service. Small and peaceful location.
Location
-
110 Main St, Geneseo, NY 14454, United States Hotline: +1 585-243-3690
Welcome, fellow food enthusiasts! Today, we delve into the delightful world of Pizza Paul's, a hidden gem nestled on 110 Main St, Geneseo, NY. Known for their savory selection of pizzas, subs, and mouthwatering sides, this establishment has captured the hearts—and taste buds—of many locals and visitors alike.
At Pizza Paul's, the dedication to quality is evident. Their pizza offerings are nothing short of exceptional. With a menu that boasts everything from classic cheese slices priced at just $6.21 to the fan-favorite double dough pizza, each bite is a celebration of texture and flavor. Patrons rave about the freshly made, generous toppings that perfectly complement the house-made sauce. For instance, a customer, Margaret Cappello, affectionately noted, "The sauce is yummy, and the quantity of toppings is just right... consistently." It's the kind of praise that speaks volumes about the restaurant's commitment to quality.
- Breadsticks: Customers like Zachary Lohouse describe them as "a medium white pizza in all but name," showcasing Pizza Paul's knack for transforming simple ingredients into an unforgettable experience.
- Wings: The BBQ wings have fans raving, with Justin Wirth declaring that the "crust is PERFECT." Fast service and great prices keep loyal customers returning week after week.
- Subs: The variety of subs, including options like the Chicken Finger Sub and the Italian Sub, ensure there is something for everyone. It’s a diverse menu that gracefully balances traditional favorites with inventive twists.
Beyond the stellar pizza, Pizza Paul's stands out for its superb customer service. Allen Russell's experience highlights the restaurant’s commitment to accommodating unique requests, especially when feeding picky eaters. This personal touch adds to the homey atmosphere, making every visit feel special.
In conclusion, if you find yourself in Geneseo, Pizza Paul's is a must-visit. Their blend of quality ingredients, diverse menu, and welcoming service create an experience that's hard to beat. Whether you're grabbing a quick slice or enjoying a family meal, you're bound to leave satisfied. Do yourself a favor and stop by—your taste buds will thank you!