Pizza Paul's Menu

  1. Home
  2. Menu

Introducing the Menu at Pizza Paul's

Located at 110 Main St in Geneseo, NY, Pizza Paul's is a beloved gem renowned for its delicious, perfectly cooked pizza and diverse menu offerings. This cozy eatery caters to every craving, featuring a variety of delectable subs, including the popular Bologna Sub and Chicken Finger Parm, all priced conveniently around $10.23. They also offer mouthwatering salads, such as the Taco Salad and the Southwest Santa Fe, both at $11.30.

  • Signature Slices: Try their Specialty Pizza Slice for just $7.30.
  • Customer Favorites: Reviews highlight their cheesy breadsticks and BBQ wings.
  • Quality Ingredients: Fresh mushrooms and ample toppings delight patrons.

Whether you're grabbing a slice or indulging in their famous garlic bread, every visit to Pizza Paul's promises a taste experience that keeps customers coming back time and time again.

Slices 6 Sub Salads

Slices

Slice Cheese
$6.21

Slice Pep
$6.49

Slice Specialty Special
$7.30

Assorted Sub

Bacon Sub

Bologna Sub Small
$10.23

Capicolla Sub

Cheese Sub

Salami Sub

Ham Sub

Italian Sub

Meatball Sub

Pizza Sub

Tuna Sub

Turkey Sub

Veggie Sub

Roast Beef Sub

Steak Sub

Cheeseburger Sub

Grilled Chicken Sub

Chicken Finger Sub

Grilled Chicken Parm Sub

Chicken Finger Parm

6 Sub

Salads

Chef Salad

Ham, turkey and provolone cheese
$11.30

Taco Salad

Tortilla shell, seasoned beef, sour cream, salsa, cheddat and olives
$11.30

Southwest Santa Fe

Tortilla shell, grilled chicken, salsa, olives, cheddar & sour cream
$11.30

Mediterranean

Grilled chicken, olives and feta
$11.30

Cranberry Cape Cod

Cranberries, mandarin oranges and feta
$11.30